1552 – 1569: Ólafur Hjaltason
1571 – 1627: Guðbrandur Þorláksson
1628 – 1656: Þorlákur Skúlason
1657 – 1684: Gísli Þorláksson
1684 – 1690: Jón Vigfússon
1692 – 1696: Einar Þorsteinsson
1697 – 1710: Björn Þorleifsson
1711 – 1739: Steinn Jónsson
1741 – 1745: Ludvig Harboe (danskur)
1746 – 1752: Halldór Brynjólfsson
1755 – 1779: Gísli Magnússon
1780 – 1781: Jón Teitsson
1784 – 1787: Árni Þórarinsson
1789 – 1798: Sigurður Stefánsson